Best Derek Jeter Rookie Baseball Card | Top 10

Discover the best Derek Jeter rookie baseball cards with our detailed guide, highlighting the most expensive Derek Jeter cards and their current market trends. We will delve into insights from recent sales to help you identify which Derek Jeter cards are worth the most money.

You are just starting your collection or looking to expand your investment portfolio, this guide will equip you with the knowledge to make smart choices. Navigate the market like a pro and uncover the top-value Jeter cards today.

Top 10 Best Derek Jeter Rookie Baseball Card

The best Derek Jeter rookie baseball card market is highly volatile, and prices can fluctuate rapidly. These figures represent the highest known sales prices as of 2023.

• 1993 Score Derek Jeter RC #489
• 1993 Select Derek Jeter RC #360
• 1993 Upper Deck Derek Jeter RC #449
• 1993 Bowman Derek Jeter RC #511
• 1993 Topps Derek Jeter RC #98
• 1993 Stadium Club Murphy Derek Jeter RC #117
• 1993 Pinnacle Derek Jeter RC #457
• 1993 Topps Gold Derek Jeter RC #98
• 1992 Little Sun Prospects Derek Jeter RC Autograph
• 1993 SP Derek Jeter RC #279

1993 Score Derek Jeter RC #489

Sale Price	$100
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	eBay

Market Analysis: Derek Jeter,the most beloved Yankees of all time, has a rookie card that’s become a must-have for collectors. Here’s a brief market analysis for the 1993 Score Derek Jeter Rookie Card #489:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 6,509
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 2,144
• PSA 9 (Mint): The rest fall into the mint 9 or lower category.

PSA 10 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $100
• PWCC Auctions (October 2023): $101
• Current Range: Typically between $100 and $105. The values reflect the card’s status in gem mint condition.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $20
• Current Range: Generally around $15 to $25.

Overview: The 1993 Score Derek Jeter RC #489 is a popular choice among collectors for its simplicity and affordability. This card shows clean image of Jeter in his Yankees uniform, making it an ideal entry point for those new to collecting Derek Jeter rookie card.

1993 Select Derek Jeter RC #360

Sale Price	$237
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	eBay

Market Analysis: This Card That Captures a Legend’s Beginnings. The card Derek Jeter in his rookie season and is part of the Select set, known for its distinctive look and higher-quality printing. Here we discuss a comprehensive analysis of its market performance:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 5,323
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 498
• PSA 9 (Mint): The remaining cards fall into mint 9 or lower grades.

PSA 10 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $237
• PWCC Auctions (October 2023): $300
• Current Range: Generally between $230 and $300. The prices reflect the card’s in gem mint condition, with some fluctuation based on auction house results and market trends.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $25
• Current Range: The current range $20 to $30

Overview: For those who appreciate understated elegance, the 1993 Select Derek Jeter RC #360 stands out with its minimalist design. This card is recognized for its sharp, glossy finish and bold colors that make Jeter’s image pop.  The sharp image of Jeter, bat on shoulder, reflects the calm and composed demeanor that became his hallmark.

1993 Upper Deck Derek Jeter RC #449

Sale Price	$260
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	PWCC Auctions

Market Analysis: The 1993 Upper Deck Derek Jeter Rookie Card #449 is a cornerstone of modern baseball card collecting. The Jeter Rookie Card is a flagship card from Jeter’s rookie year and is highly regarded among collectors. We discuss a concise market analysis for the Jeter Rookie Card.

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 13,921
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 821 
• PSA 9 (Mint): Remaining copies

PSA 10 value:

• eBay Sale (October 2023): $260
• PWCC Auctions (October 2023): $324
• Current Range: The range between $250 and $325. The value fluctuation reflects the card’s strong demand and the relative rarity of gem mint.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $25
• Current Range: Generally around $20 to $30.The price reflects the higher availability of mint condition cards.

Overview: Upper Deck’s commitment to high-quality photography shines through in the 1993 Upper Deck Derek Jeter RC #449. This card’s action shot of Jeter fielding a ground ball is a dynamic representation of his defensive prowess, making it a fan favorite and a key piece in any Derek Jeter rookie card collection.

1993 Bowman Derek Jeter RC #511

Sale Price	$291
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	eBay

Market Analysis: The 1993 Bowman Derek Jeter Rookie Card #511 is a key card in the baseball card hobby, known for its classic design and connection to Derek Jeter’s rookie season. Here’s an updated market analysis based on recent supply and value data:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 8,560
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 880
• PSA 9 (Mint):The remaining cards, with PSA 9 being the most common among the higher grades.

PSA 10 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $291
• PWCC Auctions (November 2023): $222
• Current Range: Typically between $220 and $300. The variation in price reflects market fluctuations and auction results.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $33
• Current Range: Generally around $30 to $35.

Overview: The 1993 Bowman Derek Jeter RC #511 is another classic, showcasing Jeter in a batting stance. This Rookie card pictured in a simple batting stance, the photo radiating focus and determination.

The clean lines and sharp imagery of the 1993 Bowman RC #511 offer a more mature portrayal of the young star who would go on to win the 2000 World Series MVP. The classic Bowman card design that’s become a staple for rookie card collectors.

1993 Topps Derek Jeter RC #98

Sale Price	$300
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	PWCC Auctions

Market Analysis: The 1993 Topps Derek Jeter Rookie Card #98 is the most recognized card in the hobby, highlighting the beginning of Derek Jeter’s illustrious career. Here’s a detailed analysis of its current market dynamics:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 46,978
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 3,437
• PSA 9 (Mint):The remaining cards, with PSA 9 being the most common higher grade.

PSA 10 value:

• PWCC Auction (November 2023): $300
• eBay Sale (November 2023): $285
• Current Range: Generally range between $280 and $320, depending on the seller, auction platform, and card presentation.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $30
• Current Range: Typically around $25 to $35, reflecting the availability of this grade in the market.

Overview: Topps is synonymous with baseball cards, and Jeter’s 1993 Topps RC #98 is a must-have. The Quintessential Rookie Card image shows Jeter in a fielding position, ready to make a play. The photo, combined with the traditional Topps design.

This card make a true piece of baseball history, much like Jeter’s legacy as the Yankees’ all-time hits leader. The most valuable Derek Jeter cards, this one is essential for any serious collector. The key feature of this card classic Topps design with lasting appeal.

1993 Stadium Club Murphy Derek Jeter RC #117

Sale Price	$427
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	eBay

Market Analysis: The 1993 Stadium Club Murphy Derek Jeter Rookie Card #117 is one of the more unique and sought-after Jeter rookie cards, known for its distinctive design and lower production numbers compared to other sets. Here’s a detailed market analysis:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 5,289
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 953
• PSA 9 (Mint): The remaining cards, with PSA 9 being a common high-grade for this card.

PSA 10 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $427
• PWCC Auction (October 2023): $576
• Current Range: The range between $420 and $580, depending on the platform and auction timing.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $58
• Current Range: The range around about $50 to $65, reflecting steady demand for mint-condition cards that aren’t quite gem mint.

Overview: Part of the Stadium Club Murphy set, this card features high-quality photography, capturing Jeter mid-throw. The glossy finish enhances the action shot, adding to the card’s prestige.

The image encapsulates the young shortstop’s strong arm and potential, which would lead to a Hall of Fame career. In terms of derek jeter rookie card value, this card’s rarity boosts its desirability among collectors.

The jeter rookie card value scarcity and iconic status, making it a strong long-term investment. Its PSA 10 value is expected to appreciate as demand for high-grade 1990s rookie cards grows. Increased rarity and premium finish, perfect for serious collectors.

1993 Pinnacle Derek Jeter RC #457

Sale Price	$483
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	eBay

Market Analysis: The 1993 Pinnacle Derek Jeter Rookie Card #457 is a notable card in the hobby, valued for its sleek design. Here we discuss an in-depth market analysis of this rookie card:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 8,137
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 726
• PSA 9 (Mint) or Less: The remaining cards, with PSA 9 being more common among higher grades.

PSA 10 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $483
• PWCC Auction (October 2023): $408
• Current Range: Between $400 and $500, reflecting the card’s desirability in top condition and the variation based on auction platforms and buyer interest.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $32
• Current Range: The current range around $30 to $40, indicating steady demand for this grade as an affordable option for collectors.

Overview: The 1993 Pinnacle Derek Jeter RC #457 stands out with its bold, black-bordered design. The image of Jeter, bat in hand, ready for action, gives this card a modern, edgy look. Eye-catching design with a modern edge.

The photo emphasizes Jeter’s focus and readiness, traits that defined his clutch performances in the postseason. This card’s striking design makes it a unique addition to any collection of best Derek Jeter rookie cards.

1993 Topps Gold Derek Jeter RC #98

Sale Price	$1,133
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	eBay

Market Analysis: The PSA population reports for the 1993 Topps Derek Jeter Rookie Card #98 is a premium version of the standard Jeter rookie card, featuring a gold-foil finish that distinguishes it from the regular Topps release. We explore here in-depth market analysis:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 9,917
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 426
• PSA 9 (Mint): 4,298
• NM-MT 8 or Less: The remainder of the cards, with many showing typical wear or print issues common to this era.

PSA 10 value:

• eBay Sale (October 2023): $1,133
• PWCC Auction (October 2023): $930
• Current Range: Between $900 and $1,150, reflecting the card’s rarity in gem mint condition and the premium collectors place on this gold variant.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $83
• Current Range: The range Between $80 to $100, showing a significant drop in value compared to PSA 10.

Overview: The 1993 Topps Gold Derek Jeter RC #98, featuring a gold foil nameplate and a classic fielding image, is a premium variant and the most valuable Derek Jeter cards, reflecting his illustrious career, including 14 All-Star selections and five World Series titles.

1992 Little Sun Prospects Derek Jeter RC Autograph

Sale Price	$18,600
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading	PSA 10
Auction House	Heritage Auctions

Market Analysis: The 1992 Little Sun Prospects Derek Jeter Autograph is one of the earliest and most coveted Jeter autographs in the hobby, capturing his pre MLB days. Here is a detailed market analysis:

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 27
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 5
• PSA 9 (Mint): 16
• NM-MT 8 or Less: The remaining cards, with many showing typical signs of wear or imperfections that are common in earlier, hand-signed cards.

PSA 10 value:

• Heritage Auctions (September 2023): $18,600
• PWCC Auctions (May 2023): $13,800
• Current Range: Between $13,800 and $18,600, highlighting the card’s rarity and the significant premium placed on its condition and early signature.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (October 2023): $2,572
• Current Range: Around $2,500 to $3,000, showing strong demand even in lower grades reflecting the card’s historical significance.

Overview: This pre-rookie card features a candid photo of Jeter in his high school uniform, a far cry from the pinstripes he would later don. The autograph adds a personal touch, making it is the most valuable and unique best Derek Jeter rookie cards.

It’s a glimpse into the future greatness of The Captain, who would go on to be enshrined in Cooperstown. The main key feature of this card autographed and rare, a true collector’s item from Jeter’s early days.

1993 SP Derek Jeter RC #279

Sale Price	$204,000
Sale Date	November 2023
Card Grading Grade: PSA 10	PSA 10
Auction House	PWCC Auctions

Market Analysis: The 1993 SP Derek Jeter Rookie Card #279 the most iconic and sought-after cards in modern baseball card collecting. Known for its foil finish and the difficulty of finding high-grade examples, this card holds significant value in the market.

Supply:

• Total Graded by PSA: 23,711
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): 21
• PSA 9 (Mint): 621
• NM-MT 8 or Less: The vast majority of graded cards, reflecting the difficulty in obtaining higher grades due to the card’s sensitive foil surface.

PSA 10 value:

• PWCC Auctions (December 2022): $204,000
• Goldin Auctions (December 2022): $204,000
• Heritage Auctions (November 2022): $280,000
• Current Range: Between $200,000 and $280,000, depending on the auction house and timing, with the card’s rarity in gem mint condition driving these high prices.

PSA 9 value:

• eBay Sale (November 2023): $4,797
• PWCC Auctions (November 2023): $4,080
• Current Range: The current range $4,000 to $5,000, reflecting a significant premium for high-grade examples, though much more accessible than the elusive PSA 10.

Overview: The 1993 SP RC #279 is often considered the crown jewel of best Derek Jeter rookie cards. The card’s foil finish features an iconic shot of Jeter preparing to throw, showcasing his defensive skills. The most valuable Jeter rookie card, known for its scarcity in top condition.

Its condition sensitivity makes high-grade copies exceptionally rare and valuable, much like Jeter’s career achievements. This card’s scarcity and condition sensitivity make it most valuable Derek Jeter cards on the market.

Final Discussion

The value of Derek Jeter rookie cards is essential for making savvy choices in both collecting and investing. By examining recent sales and market trends, you can identify the best Derek Jeter rookie baseball cards and focus on those most expensive Derek Jeter cards that offer the greatest potential return.

You are new to the hobby or looking to enhance your portfolio, this guide equips you with the knowledge to find Derek Jeter cards worth money. Stay informed and make strategic decisions to build a collection that truly stands out

FAQs